Tuesday, July 9, 2013

Guidance versus Self-Reflection: the Oskar Schindler Factory, Krakow

Unlike Warsaw, the city of Krakow was not destroyed and later rebuilt after the Second World War. Its medieval central square, castle, cathedrals, and even its synagogues remain—preserved, as one of our tour guides said, by the Nazis in order to serve as a sort of museum of an extinct race. Today, Krakow’s preserved history reminds today’s visitors of the city’s rich, multicultural past.

Main square, Krakow, with typical Polish summer weather

Despite the presence of very real historical buildings and locations, including the nearby Auschwitz concentration camp, Krakow’s Oskar Schindler Factory Museum also falls into the category of museums attempting to evoke certain feelings in its visitors. It strayed, however, from the idolization of national heroes that I had come to expect from Polish museums. The museum is housed in what had been Schindler’s cookware factory, where he employed several hundred Polish Jews from the nearby Kazimierz Jewish district, and later the Krakow ghetto.

The Old Synagogue, the oldest synagogue still standing in Poland
For the uninitiated, Schindler and his wife bribed the Nazis—of which Oskar Schindler was a prominent member—in order to keep their Jewish workers employed, and thus saved them from almost certain death in extermination camps after the Krakow ghetto was liquidated. Because Jews could only escape deportation by doing work directly related to the German war effort, Schindler began manufacturing anti-tank grenades. Using his connections with the Nazi party, Schindler was able to have 700 of his workers who had been sent to the concentration camp at Gross-Rosen rerouted to his munitions factory, where they waited out the rest of the war. Schindler and his wife are credited with saving the lives of 1,200 Jewish men and women from extermination.
While the museum could have easily become a shrine to the Schindlers’ heroic actions, only a small section is dedicated to the couple. The rest of the museum focuses on Krakow during the Nazi occupation (1939-45). The effect is certainly dramatic. One weaves through Nazi flags that are suspended from a hallway ceiling and into a room where the floor is paved with swastikas, forcing the visitor to trample upon the symbol of the Third Reich. Visitors can walk through a mock-up of a family’s cramped ghetto living quarters. There is contemporary film footage and audio throughout the museum, showcasing everything from weekly markets to the roundup of Jews for relocation.  There is a strong note of sympathy for all of Krakow’s residents, not just those targeted for elimination by the Nazis. Like the Warsaw Uprising Museum, the Polish population is portrayed through personal testimony and interviews sprinkled into every exhibit. While personal stories do bring the past into the present, the heroic overtones throughout the museum may again be attempting to invoke an uncomfortable level of nationalism.

Swastika floor in the Oskar Schindler Factory
 The most striking exhibit is the centerpiece of the museum, Schindler’s office, where a map of Europe discovered during construction hangs behind Schindler’s desk.[1] In the center of the room, however, is a ceiling-high glass enclosure that is filled with unfinished enamelware like that produced in the factory. Visitors can walk through the center of the cube and read the names of the 1,200 Jews that were saved: Schindler’s list.
At the end of the museum, visitors walk through a short, unlit hallway over a rubbery floor that serves as one final multi-sensory reminder of the confusion Krakow’s inhabitants faced during occupation. Just before exiting the factory into the courtyard, one is thrust into a white, circular room, where turning pillars set into the wall are reminiscent of the scrolls of the Torah. The museum calls it the Room of Choices. Printed on the walls in Hebrew, German, Polish, French, English, and other languages are quotes from those who, like the Schindlers, chose to take action against the Nazis by helping the persecuted. It is a thought-provoking way to end a visit to a museum that often seemed to have only one thought it wished to convey: that life in Krakow under Nazi occupation was horrendous. But by ending on the Room of Choices, the museum asks the visitor to look inward to his or her own morality, and ask, ‘Would I have done the same?’ In this way the museum, which until that point had borne the brunt of bringing the past into the present, forces the visitor to reflect, and carry those thoughts out into the world.


The Room of Choices, Oskar Schindler Factory


Kelsey Allagood is a Master of Arts candidate in Conflict Resolution at Georgetown University. She recently traveled to Poland and Germany with Georgetown’s School of Foreign Service in Qatar with the Zones of Conflict, Zones of Peace Program. Her travel was facilitated by Georgetown University's Master of Arts program in Conflict Resolution.

No comments:

Post a Comment